In the early 1780s, Austrian chemist Franz-Joseph Müller von Reichenstein began investigating a gold ore that’d been found in a Romanian mine. The ore contained a strange substance that Müller thought must be bismuth sulfide. This turned out not to be correct, and Müller then declared that the substance was an unknown metal that was a lot like antimony.
After three years of research, Müller discovered that the new metal didn’t resemble antimony so much after all. For this reason, Müller took to referring to the substance as aurum paradoxium (paradoxical gold) and metallum problematicum (problem metal). Even the best chemists get frustrated now and then!
Müller published a paper in a journal, announcing the discovery of a new element. But because the journal wasn’t well known, the announcement didn’t get much attention. In 1796, Müller sent some of the gold ore to famed German chemist Martin Klaproth. Klaproth confirmed that the metal (which would turn out to be a metalloid rather than a true metal) was a new element. Klaproth chose the name tellurium for the element, from the Latin word tellus, meaning Earth.
This name was in keeping with the supposed correspondence of certain metals with the planets. For example, the Moon was associated with silver, Mars with iron, Saturn with lead, Mercury with mercury, and so on. When Klaproth discovered uranium in 1789, he named the element after Uranus. So the name “tellurium,” which connected the new element with the Earth, made sense!
