Look at the periodic table, and you’ll notice that some of the elements have awfully similar names—ytterbium, yttrium, terbium, and erbium. That’s because these elements were all discovered in minerals found near the village of Ytterby, Sweden. If you have a hard time keeping these elements straight, you’re not alone!
These elements all have similar properties, so discovering many of them was a long and sometimes confusing process. That was certainly the case with erbium, which Swedish chemist Carl Gustaf Mosander discovered in a piece of gadolinite from Ytterby. Mosander thought that this chemical sample was an oxide (a compound of oxygen and some other element) called yttria. From the sample, he also separated out two other oxides, which he called “erbia” and “terbia.”
It turned out that giving these oxides such similar names wasn’t the best idea. Not long after Mosander’s discoveries, another chemist confused erbia with terbia. That mix-up caused scientists problems for more than two decades! That confusion wouldn't be cleared up until the oxides, and the elements erbium and terbium that they contained, were finally renamed.
In addition to erbium and terbium, the gadolinite that Mosander analyzed ended up containing five other new elements—ytterbium, scandium, thulium, holmium, and gadolinium. Now just try to keep the names straight!
