Weaver is sensitive to concerns about using
a nuclear device. He proposes that it would
be detonated in deep space, where, accord-
ing to his simulation, neither the explosion
nor the radioactive fallout would pose any
threat to Earth.
The real issue, according to Weaver,
is how much advance notice of a nearby
asteroid is obtained and how long it would
take to execute a mission; deflecting an
asteroid could require a two-year warning.
Yet even with an appeal to the nuclear op-
tion, there is currently no feasible defense
against asteroids more than a mile wide.
Fortunately, they rarely impact Earth. The
last occurrence was the celestial celebrity
that brought about the end of the dinosaur
age 65 million years ago.
—Kirsten Fox
Ghost of Christmas Past
On Christmas day, 2010, the Burst Alert
Telescope onboard NASA’s Swift satellite,
running software developed at Los Alamos,
detected a new type of gamma-ray burst
(GRB). GRBs are exactly what they sound
like—quick bursts of gamma rays—often
followed by less energetic radiation. Al-
though the gamma-ray component typically
lasts less than a minute, this particular burst
lasted a half hour before being followed
by an x-ray afterglow. Its emission spec-
trum, too, contained a blend of familiar and
unfamiliar features: One part resembled
an energetic jet of matter and another part
resembled a supernova; both of these are
frequently associated with stellar explo-
sions and the expanding shock waves that
accompany them. But this particular GRB
had one feature that could not be so neatly
explained as originating with an exploding
star: shortly after the shock wave broke
out of the star, it appeared to run into an
unexpected outer shell of material, emitting
a burst of ultraviolet, visible, and infrared
light. Evidently the GRB, now known as the
Christmas Burst, represents a rare astro-
nomical event.
The cause of the Christmas Burst is the
subject of lively debate in astronomy circles.
One leading hypothesis is that the GRB
originated in a binary star system in which
a red giant star with a core made of helium
closely orbited a neutron star. Eventually the
stars spiraled into each other, producing the
outburst. This scenario was originally pro-
posed in 1997 by Los Alamos computational
physicist Chris Fryer, who has continued to
pioneer theoretical efforts to better study
its characteristics. If Fryer’s scenario is
indeed the cause of Christmas Burst, then
based on the burst’s brightness, the collision
must have taken place in a distant galaxy.
An alternate proposal involves a small,
comet-like object falling onto a neutron
star and producing a much dimmer burst,
in which case it must have occurred closer,
within our Galaxy. Normally this could be
resolved by simply looking for a galaxy in
the location where the GRB was observed,
but only an inconclusive hint of a glow was
found. Indeed, Fryer and his team submit-
ted a proposal to take a longer-exposure
image of that region using the Hubble Space
Telescope, while still pursuing other ways to
identify the source of the unusual GRB.
During the year following the burst, Fryer
and Los Alamos colleague Wesley Even put
the distant stellar collision hypothesis to the
test, using a sophisticated computer simula-
tion to calculate the emission spectrum pro-
duced by such a collision. Working with an
international team of researchers running
a variety of simulations, they were able to
confirm that the observed Christmas Burst
matched the neutron star-red giant collision
model studied by Fryer and his team.
For most of its “life,” a star produces
energy by nuclear fusion, with hydrogen
nuclei in its core fusing together. But even-
tually, the hydrogen in the core fuses into
helium, which is unable to fuse with itself
to generate additional heat and pressure.
Without that source of pressure, the helium
core begins to collapse under its own
weight while the outer layers of the star,
spurred by nuclear reactions outside the
core, expand outward. The result is known
as a red giant. For massive stars, the helium
core eventually gets hot enough to ignite
further nuclear fusion and thereby produce
This artist’s conception of the Christmas Burst astronomical event shows the merger of a neutron star with a red giant star, with the resulting body
collapsing to a black hole (central dot). The collapse produces an extremely energetic jet of matter that interacts first with the collapsing stellar core
(central sphere) and then with the outer layers of the red giant star (surrounding red swirl) that were previously cast outward by the approach of
the neutron star. Los Alamos scientists recently performed a computer simulation to demonstrate how this event produced the complex pattern of
radiation observed.
CREDIT: Aurore Simonnet, Sonoma State University, and NASA
1663 los alamos science and technology magazine june 2012
23