What if the Sky Is Falling?
One doesn’t have to be paranoid to be-
lieve the sky is falling: asteroids and comets
do rain down on Earth. These rocky or icy
chunks usually orbit the sun between Mars
and Jupiter or beyond Neptune, but gravity
and collisions occasionally redirect them
inward, sometimes on a collision course
with Earth.
What happens next depends on the
size of the asteroids. Some are too small to
survive the passage through the atmo-
sphere, where they burn up. Larger objects,
however, do sometimes crash into Earth and
create craters or worse—and they don’t
need to be terribly large to be devastating.
The rock that likely exploded over Siberia in
1908 and knocked down trees for hundreds
of miles in all directions from its shockwave
alone, equal to 10–15 megatons (million
tons) of TNT, is thought to have been less
than 60 meters wide. An object only a few
times that size could not only cause tremen-
dous regional damage on land but could
also spawn deadly tsunamis from an impact
at sea—potentially reaching shorelines far
22 from the impact. Moreover, the vapor and
debris produced by a substantially larger
collision could block out the Sun, resulting
in massive climate change and numerous
extinctions. Near-Earth objects (NEOs) are asteroids
and comets in orbits that allow them to
enter Earth’s neighborhood as they orbit the
Sun. NEOs whiz through Earth’s vicinity on a
regular basis, leading the U.S. government
to launch a neighborhood watch. NASA de-
tects, tracks, and characterizes NEOs using
ground- and space-based telescopes. Ac-
cording to NASA, 8,871 near-Earth objects
have been discovered, of which 1,300 have
been classified as potentially hazardous. If
the ship-sized asteroid that passed by Earth
last year (closer than the Moon) had slightly
altered course, its impact would have been
equivalent to 10 million of the earliest atomic
bombs. This threat has led some to consider
using a nuclear energy source to disrupt
an NEO in space before it can unleash that
level of destruction down here.
Los Alamos astrophysicist Robert Weav-
er has already demonstrated this is pos-
sible. To simulate the phenomenon in 3-D,
1663 los alamos science and technology magazine june 2012
How could the world be saved from a killer asteroid?
Weaver ran a detailed simulation on Cielo,
one of the Lab’s supercomputers, to reveal
how a potentially hazardous object could
be disrupted. In January, Weaver released
a video (available online at www.youtube.
com/user/LosAlamosNationalLab) revealing
how a one-megaton nuclear energy source
might affect a half-kilometer-long asteroid
capable of destroying a continent. The
simulation shows how a single explosion
directed at the asteroid would send a shock
wave through it, impacting the individual
granite chunks comprising it and shatter-
ing the entire object. Weaver pronounced
the hazard “fully mitigated.” Score one for
happy humans, zero for killer asteroid.
“Prior to my calculations, it was merely
speculation that a nuclear source might
be a good option to deter an asteroid. We
provided the physics and hydrodynam-
ics—definitive scientific results about how
a nuclear burst could do the job,” says
Weaver. The simulation revealed that the
high velocities of the asteroid debris frag-
ments prevented them from reassembling
afterward and, in fact, caused them to
disperse well beyond their original Earth-
crossing trajectory. “It’s highly unlikely for
them to pose a secondary threat.”
Nonnuclear alternatives have been
explored previously, including conventional
explosives and some other creative ways to
steer an Earth-crossing object off course,
but according to a NASA study delivered to
Congress in 2007, a nuclear device remains
the most effective option. Nonetheless,